For those not familiar with IMVU, it appears to be a instant messaging program which uses 3d avatars instead of a regular 2d image.

I was alerted by Schadeljager that one lovely member of their community is currently passing off my oblivion mod work (which im sure a few people know of) as their own, namely my scythes and my tanzit's set. Not only that, but cultbrain's sauron armour set has also fallen victim to this thief.

You can see the items he is selling (yes, he's making money) right here. I find the comments he posts along with them quite amusing, as he really seems to be sucked in by his own lies.

"All the items available or buying from me,
my creation by the divine powers,
made by unbreakable materials to ensure perfect usage."

Yeah ok then.

After consulting Rohugh about whether it's ok, i'm posting this here so everyone can check this guy's member page and see if any of their stuff has fallen victim to plagiarism as well.

Now onto the legalities.
IMVU have a Product Flagging Policy in which it states that if your work has been plagiarised you can contact them via post or fax, but with me living outside the US and not owning a fax machine (and quite frankly not willing to pay money out of my own pocket for the postage) i've found alternate means of contacting them.

The only email adress i could find for them that wasn't either billing or development is clare@imvu.com (ironically the development email is for questions about making your own 3d assets, or stealing, you know, whichever) . If anyone else finds their work on this person's page and feels the need to email them as well, then do so. Hopefully this should raise their awareness levels about potential theft, seeing as they have no real countermeasures in place. Except of course the original owner stumbling across said items, which is not good enough frankly.

Other than that i have to say what a wonderful start to my morning! I hope nobody else's work has fallen victim to this theif, or their community in general.
This is apalling... How low is it possible to go?
wtf :S what a lame ass! swear.gif Good for noticing this though smile.gif (not that I have ever made anything but for the people who did, like you)
I hope this guy gets what he deservers fast!

I saw he's using the mask mod aswell (do not know exactly who made it, so might be reported already)
There's always some greedy, thieving twonk out to spoil it for everyone else. These people should be strung up and have Dremora do horrible things to them.
That type of worthless slug should be shot (plus many many other things) Just a suggestion, If it takes to long for them to be removed you could try posting reviews on the stolen items and A: letting people know thye are stolen and B: Providing the link to the mods on tessource so this slime doesn't get any money out of stealing other peoples work
Too bad we can't send an email to the chinese chump that's been hacking away at TESS, and give him this twit's URL.
QUOTE(AlienSlof @ Jul 12 2007, 02:20 PM) *
There's always some greedy, thieving twonk out to spoil it for everyone else. These people should be strung up and have Dremora do horrible things to them.


I reackon we teach him a lesson lucien lachance style
<h1 class="firstHeading">
</h1>
I still have an account there...if I can remember my password. I'm so tempted to leave a message.

Thanks for alerting us, now I may just go for a bit of a window-shop, and hope nothing of mine is there...not that anyone would want to steal it. But you never know.
swear.gif

This made me really angry. I should spam him.
QUOTE(AlienSlof @ Jul 12 2007, 09:20 AM) *
There's always some greedy, thieving twonk out to spoil it for everyone else. These people should be strung up and have Dremora do horrible things to them.

Even worse. They should be forced to watch CARROT TOP while listening to K-FED, all the while being molested by a horde of dremora!
This is sounding sorta YTMND-y... What to do to Eric Bauman?
The audacity of some people really amazes me. I know why you're upset and frankly I would be too, but it is sorta a compliment to you in-so-much-as he thought your work was good enough to try and pass off as his own.

We should lead a mob and lynch him.

-EDIT-
The day I find someone trying to take credit for Septim's Pride (if it ever happens hahahaha) is the day I kill someone.
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 09:34 AM) *
They should be forced to watch CARROT TOP while listening to K-FED, all the while being molested by a horde of dremora!


Lucky bastards...

tongue.gif
QUOTE(WingMaster @ Jul 12 2007, 09:41 AM) *
Lucky bastards...

tongue.gif

ROFL.
QUOTE(Karandras @ Jul 12 2007, 11:30 PM) *
and B: Providing the link to the mods on tessource so this slime doesn't get any money out of stealing other peoples work

QUOTE(M @ Jul 12 2007, 11:35 PM) *
swear.gif

This made me really angry. I should spam him.

In the voice of Neeshka from NWN2, "I can do that." evillol.sml.gif
I just remembered my password and am hovering over the message box.

People like that really annoy me. I had someone rip off my Sims work once and post it as their own. I threatened to leech all the files from their site and distribute it on WinMX unless they took it off. They swore at me and abused me and refused, even though my work was on The Sims Resource exclusively. Their site didn't last long after that once word got around.

I striketh now!
Look for a message from a "DagorZiilson." That is me.
Looks like he's stolen assets from Dawn of war as well, chaplain set etc, look identical to the models from dow...
LOOL

Put a Bomb There !!!

LOOL
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 09:42 AM) *
ROFL.


Don't laugh at my hobbies sad.gif

But yeah, that guy is an [censored].
QUOTE(Khornate @ Jul 12 2007, 02:44 PM) *
Looks like he's stolen assets from Dawn of war as well, chaplain set etc, look identical to the models from dow...


I thought that too khornate but i didn't want to blindly point fingers at his other stuff.
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 11:43 PM) *
I striketh now!
Look for a message from a "DagorZiilson." That is me.

Me too evillol.sml.gif

I'm StarMystyk.
QUOTE(WingMaster @ Jul 12 2007, 09:47 AM) *
Don't laugh at my hobbies sad.gif

But yeah, that guy is an [censored].

Or, as I called him in a message to Galahaut, a [censored]-head
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 09:49 AM) *
Or, as I called him in a message to Galahaut, a [censored]-head


Or, perhaps, a [censored] [censored] [censored]?
QUOTE(WingMaster @ Jul 12 2007, 09:51 AM) *
Or, perhaps, a [censored] [censored] [censored]?

That works too.
Or, as my dad calls me for some reason, a [male sexual organ]head
By the way, I did find an email address that was dmca@imvu.com. Not sure how useful the responses will be from that, though. You'll probably just end up with "Yeah, that's nice, send us a fax."
This means that When I will release DUNE I should contact a legal for copyrights in order for it to not be sold online?
QUOTE(PROMETHEUS_ts @ Jul 12 2007, 09:53 AM) *
This means that When I will release DUNE I should contact a legal for copyrights in order for it to not be sold online?

Exactly. TO THE PATENT OFFICE, EVERYONE!
QUOTE(PROMETHEUS_ts @ Jul 12 2007, 02:53 PM) *
This means that When I will release DUNE I should contact a legal for copyrights in order for it to not be sold online?


No promethius, so long as you put in your readme that you understand the intellectual property copyright laws and do not wish anyone to distribute your files without your permission, then you are covered. Anything you create is automatically copyrighted to you as your intellectual property, and nobody is allowed to use it to gain a profit without your permission.
QUOTE(tda @ Jul 12 2007, 09:13 AM) *
For those not familiar with IMVU, it appears to be a instant messaging program which uses 3d avatars instead of a regular 2d image.

I was alerted by Schadeljager that one lovely member of their community is currently passing off my oblivion mod work (which im sure a few people know of) as their own, namely my scythes and my tanzit's set. Not only that, but cultbrain's sauron armour set has also fallen victim to this thief.

You can see the items he is selling (yes, he's making money) right here.


FAIL!!! swear.gif

And if those armors are ported from other games, specifically the Assassin Bodysuit, I smells me a lawsuit! 676.gif

Go Bethesda, GO! Free money! 676.gif
I bought a shoutout, attacking him.
QUOTE(MystykStar @ Jul 12 2007, 02:48 PM) *
Me too evillol.sml.gif

I'm StarMystyk.



And me. evillol.sml.gif I'm Podgepig (funnily enough).


Edit: Oh, I flagged a few of the stolen items in his catalogue too. smile.gif
I posted to my IMVU homepage blog about him/her/it. I don't do blogs, but in this case it was an exception.

I really have to go now. I work tomorrow. Early. I have bookmarked this topic and shall continue to monitor that person's message page.

TTFN
cool.gif
if anyone finds his email/myspace/anything, post it here. I smell a spam war afoot emot-ninja1.gif
I hope all our regulars get a look at this thread, so they can check this out themselves.

Then I hope you sue the rat bastard tda.
screw suing the bastard, nail his chin to a wall (i'm not joking either. Plagarismists are the scum of the earth)
Once upon a time
On the internet
There was a guy
A convict from a manger
They called him the AceAngel
He was a total ass hole
And nobody knows why

He traveled all around
On release of each damn awesome mod
From Tanzit set on to Glass Scythe
With his sex slave Bill St. Smythe
He stole and stuck it all on IMVU.com

It wasn't fair
To those
From whom he stole
But did he care?
No, not
One bit
And then he had the nads
to screw
young lads!
What a piece of [censored]!
AceAngel

Ace is quite a [censored]
Other people's work has made him rich
He hired some male prostitutes
Dressed them up in 3 piece suits
His faithful team of lawyers
Made the Internet his [censored]

Till all us came along
Hit him with a rake
and banged his mom
And Mr. Angel, quite disgraced
Had all his products erased
Well, sadly, that's a lie
They're still on IMVU[dot]com

But if we all join hands
And sing this song
Then our call will reach the sky
And maybe Zeus and Thor
Will smite that [censored]
Well, it's worth a try

OH,
AceAngel
Is going down
We've got to rise up from the underground
And show AceAngel
A thing or two
About how stealing simply isn't cool
Right now we're making that our mission
And if that bastard doesn't listen
Then we'll get sick of being lawful
And brand his ass with
Something Awful!
Wait, so these modders' models and textures etc. are being used on the 3D avatars in this IMVU?

Wtf?

Hopefully IMVU can come through with this.
QUOTE(-dude- @ Jul 12 2007, 09:20 AM) *
wtf :S what a lame ass! swear.gif Good for noticing this though smile.gif (not that I have ever made anything but for the people who did, like you)
I hope this guy gets what he deservers fast!

I saw he's using the mask mod aswell (do not know exactly who made it, so might be reported already)


that would be jcarl. i'll let him know.

Edit: i have a fax machine by the way so when i get the chance i'll right something up.. any suggestions TDA?
I wasted all that time on a parody, and nobody cares?!
Lock & Load

I'm gunna hunt me a thief...

gun2.gif
QUOTE(tda @ Jul 12 2007, 09:58 AM) *
No promethius, so long as you put in your readme that you understand the intellectual property copyright laws and do not wish anyone to distribute your files without your permission, then you are covered. Anything you create is automatically copyrighted to you as your intellectual property, and nobody is allowed to use it to gain a profit without your permission.


Yep, that's correct. Actually, you don't even have to put in a notice - as was said, anything is automatically copyrighted, even your postings on this forum. You no longer even have to use the copyright symbol on anything.

The only way for something to be legally put into public domain is if you explicitly state "I release this for public use" or something similar when you offer it. If you don't say anything like that, the default is that it remains yours. One thing: if you DO release something into public domain, you can't take it back later.

Anyway... it seems that this is the world we live in today. Theft is viewed as being fine, from software theft to downloading images, songs, etc illegally. Click of a mouse or pull of a trigger - people don't see that they're the same thing. Technology is just a tool, after all - its uses can be positive or negative.




So... this guy is some crazy Korean guy?
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 04:11 PM) *
So... this guy is some crazy Korean guy?



Think on his profile it said he was living in Canada & of Italian extraction?
This is [censored]in' sickening. First that [censored] on Ebay and now this.
At least the guy on Ebay didn't explicitly take credit for the mods.
This is just as bad as that ebay auction the other day. Only this guy is actually taking credit for your work? This makes my blood boil..
QUOTE(TK-423 @ Jul 12 2007, 11:29 AM) *
This is [censored]in' sickening. First that [censored] on Ebay and now this.


Wait...someone on Ebay? When was this? I'm out of the loop on that one. dry.gif
Although, it's still not surprising there would have been someone using Ebay too.
Some guy on Ebay was selling a bunch of mods and the CS calling it a series of "patches".
This is insane. Someone should do something about this. Isn't there anything that can be done? It isn't fair that he make money when the real artists are kind enough to give it out for free. I am shocked, appalled and disgruntled. If anyone comes in contact with or finds a way to contact that...person, post it here. I bet I'm not the only one who wants to complain my heart out. I am sorely disappointed. 188.gif
The dickwad is also selling jcarl's masks...

Regarding copyrights, this came from IMVU's copyright's page:

QUOTE
What should I do if I feel my copyright has been infringed?

If you believe that a developer has violated your copyright, you should act in accordance with the DMCA ([512©(3)(a)(i - vi) and provide IMVU with a "takedown notice" in writing to the address below:

IMVU
Attn: Designated DMCA Agent
411 High Street
Palo Alto, CA 94301

The "takedown notice" should include the following information (or just use this template):


A representative list of product URL's (if more than one).
Identification of the copyrighted material used in the products from (1) above.
Information reasonably sufficient to permit the service provider to contact the complaining party, such as an address, telephone number, and, if available, an electronic mail address at which the complaining party may be contacted.
A statement that the complaining party has a good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law.
A statement that the information in the notification is accurate, and under penalty of perjury, that the complaining party is authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed.

NOTE: It is VERY important that you include a description of exactly what the copyright violation is. For example, in the case of improper catalog derivation, this must be explicitly stated.

Once the complaint has been verified, IMVU will disable the product in the catalog. IMVU will then alert the developer(s) who submitted the items in question and provide them with an opportunity to send a written notice to IMVU stating that the material has been wrongly removed. IMVU will make reasonable and good faith efforts to alert any affected users to corresponding product changes.
Dick head needs to stop stealing and go back to sucking himself.
Being part of some modding communities, I know that this stuff is, sadly, not to uncommon. Second life has the same problem with people stealing things and selling them as their own. But seeing that Imvu page just sickens me. Do they even look at the stuff they agree to sell?
Funny, all of the responses regarding the theft of this stuff and links to this thread have been removed from the comments section of his homepage.

I sure hope you all are able to get IMVU to remove your stuff from his developer’s page...
He just posted this in his blog:

QUOTE
Hey to all,

I wanted to blog something which people seem to be having an issue on my back, and that is 'copyright' infringement of items on my behalf. Basically what some people are claiming is that I'm stealing peoples work and putting them up as mine. Ripping countless 3D Mesh Models, and converting them IMVU compatible. Also, that I'm a l33t hacker with skillz comparable to that of Gandalf, and that my real name is "The Stig". Sure, I also throw pink fireballs out of my hands, shoot green lazer beam out of eye's and have 4 balls. Please...

Well, here is the bombshell people, and that is I don't rip other people...at least not the Model issue people are talking about (and I'm a normal person).

What I do is this, I browse the internet, search for something 'cool' or tempting and take the idea...I make it and use it in IMVU simple as that. My 40K items come from GW's table-top game. They made everything, all I did was like the idea, take it, make it (the same as I saw) and made them on IMVU.

Same with game Mods, I saw a game Mod, looked at it, liked the idea, made the idea into IMVU and voila, I and people are happy.

Is it wrong? So am I really breaking any rules here? Yes and No.

You see, stealing idea's is bad, and I admit that, but there is NO rule AT ALL that says an idea or item is Righted to a person, no matter what people say I'm doing nothing wrong here. What about Naruto? Gyver? Halo? WH40K? They're all original ideas, but yet people seem to rip those with no problems, and name them no problem. But when I rip and Idea, and take all measure to protect myself from TOS violations I still get banged? KMA.

What about people who ACTUALLY make money off 3D items? I have seen countless people here ripping 3D Models which are not theirs, and the next day I see that 3D Model on a site which sells for about 200 bucks. Considering you cannot reverse an IMVU item from .CFL to 3D then I think it doesn't get any brainier. The IMVU person bought the Model and ripped to IMVU. NOW THAT is wrong.

So I want to know this, if I make an item, based upon a Mod I saw or Game I played, and idea WAS NOT mine (ideas are like speech, you cannot copyright them) I get spanked and people call me 'ripper' but when someone still a COMPLETE 3D Model and names it EVEN the same name of the spoof it was ripped from don't even get as much as a slap on the hands?

Well, I'm glad to say that from now on, who EVER claims I rip anything will be blocked by me. Lets face it, IMVU has a terrible customer service, so me complaining about harassment just won't do. I'll just have to block that person and get on with my life (and hopefully them too).

Just wanted to say that I don't rip people. I just 'get' the idea and put it up in IMVU. If that is wrong then go and complain to the DMCA institution, I didn't make and rules and I'm sure as hell playing the in the courtfield allowed to me.

So cheers, and ciao to all.


He admits to stealing ideas, sure. Doesn't even touch how he's "converting" them to IMVUs.

By "convert" does he mean, "download your meshes and textures and rigging them to an IMVU? "
this is the second time somthing like this has happened this month... aye aye aye.... disapprove.gif
QUOTE(SPARTAN VI @ Jul 12 2007, 01:02 PM) *
He just posted this in his blog:
He admits to stealing ideas, sure. Doesn't even touch how he's "converting" them to IMVUs.

By "convert" does he mean, "download your meshes and textures and rigging them to an IMVU? "


you know all he had to do was say "original model done by TDA, Jcarl etc"
Wow.. the idiot claiming now he saw them and then remade them bit by bit for imvu yet oddly they look EXACLY like the ones from the mods he "copyed" them from. There logic for you.
Oh well, idiots will be idiots.
It jack asses like this guy that ruin oblivion mods, Now many modder are going to be WAY more hesitant to make, or release 100% original mods case little weasel like this guy steals mods and profits. Thou lucky for us the idiots took the Dark botherdhood armor, and bethesda profiting of it own work is illegal.
ok, anyone know a hacker? my bro knows someone with a copy of happyfunlove32...
QUOTE(Vetto @ Jul 12 2007, 12:17 PM) *
It jack asses like this guy that ruin oblivion mods, Now many modder are going to be WAY more hesitant to make, or release 100% original mods case little weasel like this guy steals mods and profits. Thou lucky for us the idiots took the Dark botherdhood armor, and bethesda profiting of it own work is illegal.



Best thing to do is to make a account and flag it for what it is.. stolen work.
I happen to know a guy who made a virus... too bad I don't know his email address
QUOTE(Vetto @ Jul 12 2007, 12:17 PM) *
It jack asses like this guy that ruin oblivion mods, Now many modder are going to be WAY more hesitant to make, or release 100% original mods case little weasel like this guy steals mods and profits. Thou lucky for us the idiots took the Dark botherdhood armor, and bethesda profiting of it own work is illegal.


Is that exactly the Dark Brotherhood armor? Cause if it is, someone should report that to Bethesda...if we can't get anything done about him, surely they could.
QUOTE(TheCandleThief @ Jul 12 2007, 01:27 PM) *
Is that exactly the Dark Brotherhood armor? Cause if it is, someone should report that to Bethesda...if we can't get anything done about him, surely they could.

Yep, it IS the DB armor, but he'll pull an eBaum and claim it's not.
QUOTE(TheCandleThief @ Jul 12 2007, 12:27 PM) *
Is that exactly the Dark Brotherhood armor? Cause if it is, someone should report that to Bethesda...if we can't get anything done about him, surely they could.


Even so much as copying it or using it texture is enough for a law suit it large scale copy right infringement, the design itself is copy right Beth.
Smells like a law suit grad.gif
QUOTE(Vetto @ Jul 12 2007, 01:30 PM) *
Even so much as copying it or using it texture is enough for a law suit it large scale copy right infringement, the design itself is copy right Beth.

Yeah, exactly.
Thing is, Eric Bauman stole from large scale operations (Newgrounds) and got away with it, as most likely will this guy.
QUOTE(Brandon @ Jul 12 2007, 01:06 PM) *
you know all he had to do was say "original model done by TDA, Jcarl etc"

He still wouldn't of had permission to use them. Maybe if he had asked first before doing ANYTHING. But he didn't, and not only that he's charging people for them!. He took others works and tried to pass off them off as his own. And now that he's been caught in his own lies, he's trying to wry his way out of consequence. What he's doing would be like if someone here used Cethegus utility belt and tried to pass it off as their own. It's not only insulting to the people he's deceiving and the community, but also insulting to the author. It's the authors right to specify whether or not his works can be used in other projects.

And I doubt Bethesda is going to be happy WITH THIS and WITH THIS! Moderators! Look at these links and contact your superiors. USE THIS for his personal information.

Quote : "I'm currently residing in Libya, in Benghazi. I go to an European school and have been doing so in the past 6 years or so, goes figures eh?"

No comment...

QUOTE(TheCandleThief @ Jul 12 2007, 01:27 PM) *
Is that exactly the Dark Brotherhood armor? Cause if it is, someone should report that to Bethesda...if we can't get anything done about him, surely they could.

That's the Dark Brotherhood armor mesh but the texture looks like TaylorSD's stealth armor...
QUOTE(Ryu Doppler @ Jul 12 2007, 01:34 PM) *
He still wouldn't of had permission to use them. Maybe if he had asked first before doing ANYTHING. But he didn't, and not only that he's charging people for them!. He took others works and tried to pass off them off as his own. And now that he's been caught in his own lies, he's trying to wry his way out of consequence. What he's doing would be like if someone here used Cethegus utility belt and tried to pass it off as their own. It's not only insulting to the people he's deceiving and the community, but also insulting to the author. It's the authors right to specify whether or not his works can be used in other projects.

And I doubt Bethesda is going to be happy WITH THIS and WITH THIS! Moderators! Look at these links and contact your superiors. USE THIS for his personal information.

Quote : "I'm currently residing in Libya, in Benghazi. I go to an European school and have been doing so in the past 6 years or so, goes figures eh?"

No comment...

If I knew it would make a difference, I'd WALK to Rockville to tell Bethesda about the bastard!
QUOTE(Cosmic-Banana @ Jul 12 2007, 12:35 PM) *
That's the Dark Brotherhood armor mesh but the texture looks like TaylorSD's stealth armor...

Good Lord, it keeps getting worse and worse! ooo.gif
My only relief in all this is that out of all of Jcarl's work, he was only able to get his hands on Jcarls masks...

Think how bad it would have been if Jcarl had finished ALL of his works, and this guy got his hands on them...

@Jcarl: Still waiting for that Mortal Kombat, and Ninja Gaiden gear...Ryu needs to be a Lin Kuei Ninja and a Hayabusa at least once...
If the texture work is really taking that long...let me have a crack at it. If you would appreciate my help, PM me about it.
While reading this thread, I'm starting to wonder--while it sucks that he stole people's ideas and very slightly modified the files and is passing them off as his own, I'm not sure if anything can be done about it. However, he is SELLING mods which is, I believe, illegal because (correct me if I'm wrong) I was under the impression that all mods made by the CS are Bethesda's property and thus he is selling Bethesda's property which is very illegal and thus someone should contact Bethesda so they can nail the jerk.
I'll get a ride to Rockville.
QUOTE(JDStrider @ Jul 12 2007, 01:58 PM) *
While reading this thread, I'm starting to wonder--while it sucks that he stole people's ideas and very slightly modified the files and is passing them off as his own, I'm not sure if anything can be done about it. However, he is SELLING mods which is, I believe, illegal because (correct me if I'm wrong) I was under the impression that all mods made by the CS are Bethesda's property and thus he is selling Bethesda's property which is very illegal and thus someone should contact Bethesda so they can nail the jerk.

true.. but you see the models are created using either blender or 3ds max.. soo the CS has nothing to do with it
I'm on the phone with them right now
QUOTE(Brandon @ Jul 12 2007, 12:03 PM) *
true.. but you see the models are created using either blender or 3ds max.. soo the CS has nothing to do with it


Oh ok, now I think I understand. So what this guy is doing is look at mods, taking the ideas, then recreating them using blender or 3ds max? What a [censored].
They know about the jerk-off, and they're making an account right now, I believe.
QUOTE(JDStrider @ Jul 12 2007, 08:10 PM) *
Oh ok, now I think I understand. So what this guy is doing is look at mods, taking the ideas, then recreating them using blender or 3ds max? What a [censored].


Which noone actually should believe. If you look at them, he directly ripped the models. Now he's trying to cover it up with petty lies.

Has anyone else emailed Relic or THQ? I have, but I reckon it'll be better if more people do it.
QUOTE(JDStrider @ Jul 12 2007, 02:10 PM) *
Oh ok, now I think I understand. So what this guy is doing is look at mods, taking the ideas, then recreating them using blender or 3ds max? What a [censored].


nah.. tda and jcarl created those models in either blender (jcarl) or 3ds max (TDA) so the cs and beth has nothing to do with it.
what this guy did was download those mods and convert the files to use in imvu. so basically he ripped TDA and Jcarls models right off.

what he should have done is 1) said the original creators and contacted them and @) made them free.. which gives me an idea
some one with an account conver these files and more and host them for free with the original creators blessings and throw them in his face.. anyone?
I just gave Bethsoft a phonecall...
The only way that his claim of "recreating" the items is going to hold any water would be for him to post wireframes, uv layouts and texture sheets that clearly show a major difference between his models and the originals. Otherwise, he's going to get thrown off that website by the admins there, i guarantee it.

It would also be a laugh riot if THQ got wind of this, and if those meshes of the assassin stuff did actually belong to bethesda. This guy's got nowhere to turn.
Release the hounds lawyers. We should contact Beth, I remember they had a fit when the Ordinator armor was released and the moder had to PROVE that they made their own meshes and textures.
TDA, feareth not. That dick is screwed. I just got off the phone with Mark of Tech support, acting as a Deepthroat-style informant.
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 08:14 PM) *
TDA, feareth not. That dick is screwed. I just got off the phone with Mark of Tech support, acting as a Deepthroat-style informant.

LOL 24.gif Lynch the bastard!
seriousl;y, if someone knows a hacker (or this bastered's address).... let me know.
Sounds like we got him with a forked stick. happy.gif
Let's see him argue with a lawyer at his throat.
QUOTE(tda @ Jul 12 2007, 08:13 PM) *
It would also be a laugh riot if THQ got wind of this, and if those meshes of the assassin stuff did actually belong to bethesda. This guy's got nowhere to turn.


I emailed them, and I hope others do the same.

Seriously, the guy is caught with his hands in the cookiejar, and he's trying to persuade us he made his own cookiejar and cookies.
TDA, feareth not. That dick is screwed. I just got off the phone with Mark of Tech support, acting as a Deepthroat-style informant.


Now that sound like a whole lot of hurt is going to heading his way...Talk about the [censored]e hitting the fan....!!! LMAO

Sheathana'ich
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 02:19 PM) *
Let's see him argue with a lawyer at his throat.



HAHAHA i cann't wait for this guy to get ripped apart!
Thank God for Unlimited Long Distance!
DEEPTHROAT'D!
MUHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

KILL! KILL! KILL! KILL! KILLKILLKILLKILLKILLKILLKILL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

their gonna tear his wallet apart
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 02:28 PM) *
MUHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

KILL! KILL! KILL! KILL! KILLKILLKILLKILLKILLKILLKILL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

their gonna tear his soul apart and feed it to wolves
Fix'd
It's bad enough stealing from a large-scaling company, but stealing artist's hard work, WHICH THEY DISTRIBUTE FOR FREE, and selling it is below bottom line.
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 10:22 AM) *
ok, anyone know a hacker? my bro knows someone with a copy of happyfunlove32...



QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 11:19 AM) *
seriousl;y, if someone knows a hacker (or this bastered's address).... let me know.


Seriously, try the legal route, we don't need a lynch mob.



From that guys website:
QUOTE
What about people who ACTUALLY make money off 3D items? I have seen countless people here ripping 3D Models which are not theirs, and the next day I see that 3D Model on a site which sells for about 200 bucks. Considering you cannot reverse an IMVU item from .CFL to 3D then I think it doesn't get any brainier. The IMVU person bought the Model and ripped to IMVU. NOW THAT is wrong.


So apparently it's only wrong if only few people are doing it, but if everyone is doing it, then it's woo-hoo time! And even then, if you don't know what you're talking about, then it's ok, right?


QUOTE
Just wanted to say that I don't rip people. I just 'get' the idea and put it up in IMVU. If that is wrong then go and complain to the DMCA institution, I didn't make and rules and I'm sure as hell playing the in the courtfield allowed to me.


Knockoffs and rips are two different things, and if the original artist says you've done a rip, well...
QUOTE(Aorawn @ Jul 12 2007, 02:31 PM) *
It's bad enough stealing from a large-scaling company, but stealing artist's hard work, WHICH THEY DISTRIBUTE FOR FREE, and selling it is below bottom line.

Hell hath no place for such SCUM. Bauman, YOU'RE NEXT!
Hey guys, tone down the mortal threats. We can all see this kid is a degenerate low-life that feels the need to steal tda's - and many other's - work to feel any inkling of self-confidence. I mean thats what it boils down to. He can't make anything original so he has to steal the work from high-class 3d modellers like tda. Once you realize that you can tell that hes not really living at all, but hes living somebody elses life.

Anyway, I thought Bethesda made claims to all mods and resources associated with the game. Won't Bethesda be all over this in a very very short time. This kid won't make it to the men's room...
Omg, I hope Besthedia does something about this son of a [censored].... He should be sued
QUOTE(justsomeguy @ Jul 12 2007, 02:34 PM) *
Omg, I hope Besthedia does something about this son of a [censored].... He should be sued

HE WILL BE.
Bye-bye, AceAngel.
I also see Waalx' FatherSword up there... what a moron...
When will these people learn...
Yep.
o-This is your butthole.
O=This is your butthole in prison.
I have been a professional artist for some 37 yrs and applaud everyone here who spoke up and helped get the word to the mod creators and to Beth about this pirate counterfiter. It is theft pure and simple to steal any part of a creative concept or work without permission and attribution. No clever language or manipulative posting by the pirate will change the fact that he stole thw works in question. And I would echo others in saying, let Bethesda handle it with the proper proceedures, and I am very glad they are, it sounds like, and that will be a good lesson for this wrongdoer. I am glad to see such support of creative rights, and care for the community. smile.gif
I know this sounds a bit grim, but... I wonnder what's the kiddie's name on this forum... If you know what I mean... wink.gif
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 06:40 PM) *
Yep.
o-This is your butthole.
O=This is your butthole in prison.


799.gif

Nice!
QUOTE(CrisG9 @ Jul 12 2007, 02:40 PM) *
I have been a professional artist for some 37 yrs and applaud everyone here who spoke up and helped get the word to the mod creators and to Beth about this pirate counterfiter. It is theft pure and simple to steal any part of a creative concept or work without permission and attribution. No clever language or manipulative posting by the pirate will change the fact that he stole thw works in question. And I would echo others in saying, let Bethesda handle it with the proper proceedures, and I am very glad they are, it sounds like, and that will be a good lesson for this wrongdoer. I am glad to see such support of creative rights, and care for the community. smile.gif

I called them DIRECTLY.
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 06:42 PM) *
I called them DIRECTLY.



So what did they say?
QUOTE(Akuso @ Jul 12 2007, 02:45 PM) *
So what did they say?

I told Mark the site, he made an account, and I told him the username. Of course, I informed them of the theft also.
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 06:46 PM) *
I told Mark the site, he made an account, and I told him the username. Of course, I informed them of the theft also.


Cool, i hope the thief gets what he deserves, whatever that may be.
QUOTE(Akuso @ Jul 12 2007, 02:51 PM) *
Cool, i hope the thief gets what he deserves, whatever that may be.

A suit. That's his gift. A nice, comfortable, expensive, LAWSUIT.
oh yeah! another who's using my work, here thankfully it's only the Father Sword.

I was on that crazy *"&/?/ kid website banana something and these kids where displaying RealSwords modules as if they did them...

one of those times you wish you can pass through your screen and strangle the moron thief.

yet sadly it always happen. but the fact he's doing money is something else now....

I don't really know about all the lawsuit thing. Maybe just scaring him for good might be the easiest. But a lawsuit would definantly suit him too.
I just Hope this turn of events won't discourage some of are great modders -cough- tda -cough- to stop work on there great mods.
Don't want to read six pages of comments but if someone knows how they might want to send an email about this to the GamesWorkshop company which created the Warhammer series of games and this [censored] is stealing their ideas as well. Since they are a big company they can definately get him in trouble (which I hope will happen, soon!)
QUOTE(Atarau @ Jul 12 2007, 02:52 PM) *
I don't really know about all the lawsuit thing. Maybe just scaring him for good might be the easiest. But a lawsuit would definantly suit him too.

Money... fing05.gif
Besides he deserves it gun2.gif
QUOTE(waalx @ Jul 12 2007, 06:53 PM) *
oh yeah! another who's using my work, here thankfully it's only the Father Sword.

I was on that crazy *"&/?/ kid website banana something and these kids where displaying RealSwords modules as if they did them...

one of those times you wish you can pass through your screen and strangle the moron thief.

yet sadly it always happen. but the fact he's doing money is something else now....


This happened to you before? When was that?
QUOTE(waalx @ Jul 12 2007, 02:53 PM) *
oh yeah! another who's using my work, here thankfully it's only the Father Sword.

I was on that crazy *"&/?/ kid website banana something and these kids where displaying RealSwords modules as if they did them...

one of those times you wish you can pass through your screen and strangle the moron thief.

yet sadly it always happen. but the fact he's doing money is something else now....


Haha, if I were a thief, a single call from a lawyer would send me one the double to taking down my "work". Lawyers - to both parties - are just plain expensive to deal with.
QUOTE(guiltfeeder566 @ Jul 12 2007, 08:56 PM) *
Money... fing05.gif
Besides he deserves it gun2.gif

Cost money to sue also. Hopefully not more than what they can profit from it tongue.gif And yes, he definantly deserve it smile.gif
QUOTE(Akuso @ Jul 12 2007, 02:57 PM) *
This happened to you before? When was that?



I just said it..

I did a search on Realswords on Google one day to see what I can come up with as result...

and I found this website that was saying they did the Realswords modules I released so far, and offered them as download..

now I know many other place put up the files up for download as I saw that day, but they did not say the work was theirs.

Anyway, having been in many web community about 3d modelling and illustration for a while, these things happen all the times. And sometimes by very famous artist and with very known work.

Problem is unless it's a company that stole your work and sell it as a product, you have no real means. The only thing we can do about this kid is warn him, and also ask the admins of the website he distribute 'our' stuff to cancel his account, and ban him.

He also stole The Unholy Edge by LostInGeneral, a Frostmourne model available on TESSource which I can't find because "Search" is offline, and the Holy Edge is also a model that can be found on TESSource... poor guy meh.gif
QUOTE(INS4N3 @ Jul 12 2007, 02:35 PM) *
Hey guys, tone down the mortal threats. We can all see this kid is a degenerate low-life that feels the need to steal tda's - and many other's - work to feel any inkling of self-confidence. I mean thats what it boils down to. He can't make anything original so he has to steal the work from high-class 3d modellers like tda. Once you realize that you can tell that hes not really living at all, but hes living somebody elses life.

Anyway, I thought Bethesda made claims to all mods and resources associated with the game. Won't Bethesda be all over this in a very very short time. This kid won't make it to the men's room...


Beth claims legal rights over any mod we make using the CS. Any meshes and textures we make that were made using tools Beth did not create are your own property unless otherwise stated in the programs contract. Either way it's either the creators property or the company's so he is stealing regardless.
God this thread is growing too fast, I've tried to read most of it, but it keeps growing, & I just want to ask tda, is Bethesda going to do anything about it? (Have the mods said anything?)

I sure hope so, seeing they are profiting off the backs of many. dry.gif
QUOTE(wolfpup @ Jul 12 2007, 03:10 PM) *
God this thread is growing too fast, I've tried to read most of it, but it keeps growing, & I just want to ask tda, is Bethesda going to do anything about it? (Have the mods said anything?)

I sure hope so, seeing they are profiting off the backs of many. dry.gif

I called Bethsoft, and they are attempting to remedy it now.
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 12:11 PM) *
I called Bethsoft, and they are attempting to remedy it now.


I was just coming back to edit it saying, figures, someone said they where talking to them now... about three posts after I stopped reading the thread. blush.gif
QUOTE(wolfpup @ Jul 12 2007, 03:13 PM) *
I was just coming back to edit it saying, figures, someone said they where talking to them now... about three posts after I stopped reading the thread. blush.gif

That would be me that was talking to them.
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 12:16 PM) *
That would be me that was talking to them.


I know. wink.gif

(Guess I should have been more clear.)
I'm notifying Legal as we speak.
QUOTE(Gstaff @ Jul 12 2007, 12:23 PM) *
I'm notifying Legal as we speak.


Get 'em Gstaff, & company.

toughninja.gif

And thanks. smile.gif
QUOTE(Gstaff @ Jul 12 2007, 02:23 PM) *
I'm notifying Legal as we speak.



Ohhh I smell ownage.
1st Moderator to reply to the thread! I was wondering when one would show up. foodndrink.gif
I hope they nail that bastard. glare.gif
QUOTE(Gstaff @ Jul 12 2007, 03:23 PM) *
I'm notifying Legal as we speak.

Wooo gogogo
QUOTE(Gstaff @ Jul 12 2007, 02:23 PM) *
I'm notifying Legal as we speak.

Give him heck! wub.gif
QUOTE(Gstaff @ Jul 12 2007, 03:23 PM) *
I'm notifying Legal as we speak.


get the theiving little [censored] lol
QUOTE(Ryu Doppler @ Jul 12 2007, 08:24 PM) *
1st Moderator to reply to the thread! I was wondering when one would show up. foodndrink.gif


right after i PM'd him ;p
QUOTE(Ryu Doppler @ Jul 12 2007, 12:24 PM) *
1st Moderator to reply to the thread! I was wondering when one would show up. foodndrink.gif


*cough*communitymanager/admin*cough*modsaregreen*cough*


Not to be a nit picker or anything. tongue.gif


So, how long do you think till we see removal?

Placing bets. [/Rhetorical]

QUOTE(wolfpup @ Jul 12 2007, 10:29 PM) *
*cough*communitymanager/admin*cough*modsaregreen*cough*
Not to be a nit picker or anything. tongue.gif
So, how long do you think till we see removal?

Placing bets. [/Rhetorical]

tongue.gif

Within a day, I believe.
12 hours tops... one call from a high profile gaming company will send most people into a "take down" frenzy.
ARGGHH! I don't like this one bit... They better not be trying to sell my M.O.E.!
QUOTE(wolfpup @ Jul 12 2007, 09:29 PM) *
So, how long do you think till we see removal?

Placing bets. [/Rhetorical]


I'm more interested in the thread we may be seeing here within a day or so:

"YOUO BASTURDS! YUO MAED TEHM DELTELE MY TINHGS!"
Someone should do something about that jerk, but frankly I think its kind of funny there are people stupid enough to try buying that stuff off him in the first place.
I'm tempted to start an account their called, You are Screwed, & leave nasty comments, but I'm to nice for that. heee.gif

Well, maybe.

*drop kicks AceAngel*

Ok, I feel better. smile.gif

(I wont for any mods/community managers reading this, it's just how I feel.)
QUOTE(Lurid @ Jul 12 2007, 03:40 PM) *
I'm more interested in the thread we may be seeing here within a day or so:

"YOUO BASTURDS! YUO MAED TEHM DELTELE MY TINHGS!"


i'm tempted to moniter this site 24/7 just for that.... I just can't wait till the flame-fest US---> sterb032.gif flamed.gif <--him.... yeah, I think that pretty muth covers it...

QUOTE(Seigfried @ Jul 12 2007, 03:43 PM) *
Someone should do something about that jerk, but frankly I think its kind of funny there are people stupid enough to try buying that stuff off him in the first place.


the ass is being kicked as we speak.
I just went to the site and he says there's "NO rule AT ALL that says an idea or item is Righted to a person" . . . I think he misunderstands that when a person does a piece of art ( thats what these mods are ) it's automatic full rights reserved for at least 100+ years. Hopefully IMVU records the amount of sales he's made with each of these items, since when someone sells an item like this all the money and sometimes a lot more has to go back to the respective artists.

Just remember to refer to your mod sites like tessource.net for the dates of creation/release and he'll be down in a count.
QUOTE(Yiyas @ Jul 12 2007, 03:57 PM) *
I just went to the site and he says there's "NO rule AT ALL that says an idea or item is Righted to a person" . . . I think he misunderstands that when a person does a piece of art ( thats what these mods are ) it's automatic full rights reserved for at least 100+ years. Hopefully IMVU records the amount of sales he's made with each of these items, since when someone sells an item like this all the money and sometimes a lot more has to go back to the respective artists.

Just remember to refer to your mod sites like tessource.net for the dates of creation/release and he'll be down in a count.


HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[censored] [censored]tard theif.... lol
QUOTE(Yiyas @ Jul 12 2007, 03:57 PM) *
I just went to the site and he says there's "NO rule AT ALL that says an idea or item is Righted to a person" . . . I think he misunderstands that when a person does a piece of art ( thats what these mods are ) it's automatic full rights reserved for at least 100+ years. Hopefully IMVU records the amount of sales he's made with each of these items, since when someone sells an item like this all the money and sometimes a lot more has to go back to the respective artists.

Just remember to refer to your mod sites like tessource.net for the dates of creation/release and he'll be down in a count.

I thought it was like 35 years...
QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 03:59 PM) *
I thought it was like 35 years...


actully, it's five years, for normal things... but it dosen't really matter
QUOTE(INS4N3 @ Jul 12 2007, 03:36 PM) *
12 hours tops... one call from a high profile gaming company will send most people into a "take down" frenzy.

So true!
I must've been thinking music >.> oh well... it's still enough to take him down!
QUOTE(SPARTAN VI @ Jul 12 2007, 06:02 PM) *
He just posted this in his blog:
He admits to stealing ideas, sure. Doesn't even touch how he's "converting" them to IMVUs.

By "convert" does he mean, "download your meshes and textures and rigging them to an IMVU? "


Interesting that he's admiting to taking GW designs - I used to work for Games Workshop for 4 years and know that they are very protective of their own IP as it took a lot of money and time to develop them. I think It's time I phoned a few friends that are still with the company and are now middle managers as I'm pretty sure they will take it further.
QUOTE(Yiyas @ Jul 12 2007, 02:57 PM) *
Just remember to refer to your mod sites like tessource.net for the dates of creation/release and he'll be down in a count.


Hmm...Tessource is down, a lot of their data was just scrambled by a hacker...so that might be tough. Maybe they could check back through the forum release threads or something.
QUOTE(TheCandleThief @ Jul 12 2007, 04:13 PM) *
Hmm...Tessource is down, a lot of their data was just scrambled by a hacker...so that might be tough. Maybe they could check back through the forum release threads or something.


Maybe it was Aceangel tongue.gif

Seriously though let's not rule this out, it COULD be him....
QUOTE(needahearth @ Jul 12 2007, 04:14 PM) *
Maybe it was Aceangel tongue.gif

Seriously though let's not rule this out, it COULD be him....


look at his excuses and lies. he's not smart enough to be a hacker.
QUOTE(TheCandleThief @ Jul 12 2007, 01:13 PM) *
Hmm...Tessource is down, a lot of their data was just scrambled by a hacker...so that might be tough. Maybe they could check back through the forum release threads or something.


Well, it is up, but it has been hacked.

The files are missing there Download description, it just says File, instead of File TESView 1.XX kinda thing.
QUOTE(needahearth @ Jul 12 2007, 03:14 PM) *
Maybe it was Aceangel tongue.gif

Seriously though let's not rule this out, it COULD be him....

You know, it IS rather convienent timing....but that was before we even started contacting higher-ups and stuff, so I guess it's just an odd coincidence.
QUOTE(Axil @ Jul 12 2007, 11:10 PM) *
Interesting that he's admiting to taking GW designs - I used to work for Games Workshop for 4 years and know that they are very protective of their own IP as it took a lot of money and time to develop them. I think It's time I phoned a few friends that are still with the company and are now middle managers as I'm pretty sure they will take it further.

Do that!
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 09:17 PM) *
look at his excuses and lies. he's not smart enough to be a hacker.


how many script kiddies are smart? tongue.gif
QUOTE(refraction @ Jul 12 2007, 04:18 PM) *
how many script kiddies are smart? tongue.gif

Touche, good sir.
QUOTE(refraction @ Jul 12 2007, 04:18 PM) *
how many script kiddies are smart? tongue.gif


most of the ones i've met
woah.... ten minutes and no post.... whats going on? everyone go to lunch?
I went to gamestop and bought Just Cause... But, that's not edible, so no. happy.gif
QUOTE(WingMaster @ Jul 12 2007, 04:41 PM) *
I went to gamestop and bought Just Cause... But, that's not edible, so no. happy.gif


just cause?
QUOTE(Gstaff @ Jul 12 2007, 08:23 PM) *
I'm notifying Legal as we speak.


Good to know you guys are on it as well. I've yet to hear back from any @imvu.com emails.
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 04:38 PM) *
woah.... ten minutes and no post.... whats going on? everyone go to lunch?

Things are just slowing down since the official reply from Gstaff.

Basically it's a waiting game to see just how this guy is gonna get ripped a new one... bubbly.gif
QUOTE(tda @ Jul 12 2007, 08:45 PM) *
I've yet to hear back from any @imvu.com emails.


I hope they will take the time to contact you, it's the least they could do.
If they do contact you, please let us know about it, ok?
any bets on how muth this guys gonna be sued for?
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 09:57 PM) *
any bets on how muth this guys gonna be sued for?


i doubt he will get sued.

minimum action will probably be all his sales removed, most action will be his account gets cancelled.

i doubt they will do any more.
Go to this page:

http://ace-angel.deviantart.com/

and you can see his smilin' face plus his hotmail account etc.

QUOTE(refraction @ Jul 12 2007, 10:59 PM) *
i doubt he will get sued.

minimum action will probably be all his sales removed, most action will be his account gets cancelled.

i doubt they will do any more.


If the dude made money off Bethesda products then he could be in some deep [censored].
QUOTE(refraction @ Jul 12 2007, 04:59 PM) *
i doubt he will get sued.

minimum action will probably be all his sales removed, most action will be his account gets cancelled.

i doubt they will do any more.


what about the mods he's sold already?
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 05:04 PM) *
what about the mods he's sold already?

IMVU will take care of that via suit.
QUOTE(Atarau @ Jul 12 2007, 10:02 PM) *
If the dude made money off Bethesda products then he could be in some deep [censored].


i know, and i agree, it sucks.
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 10:04 PM) *
what about the mods he's sold already?



no idea, thats down to IMVU, they might take the money back off him? who knows.
where does this guy live?
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 02:12 PM) *
where does this guy live?


Good question, seeing it said Spain earlier, & it know says Canada. blink.gif
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 05:12 PM) *
where does this guy live?

His mom's basement.
I don't think anyone is going to get sued really. I threatened "legal action" in my email to imvu to try and provoke them into action, but to be honest if they called my bluff i'd back down. To hell if i'm spending money on a solicitor just because some little twit who's not got two braincells to rub together decided he would rip my stuff.

All i really want to happen is for imvu to remove my work from his page and possibly ban him from the site, that would suit me just fine. It's the work i care about more than anything else, he can soon be forgotten.
Maybe this guy is in a big oblivion mod hating conspiracy with that guy who hack-tastified tessource.
Break out the grill everyone, ITS BARBECUE TIME!!!
QUOTE(wolfpup @ Jul 12 2007, 05:13 PM) *
Good question, seeing it said Spain earlier, & it know says Canada. blink.gif


if he lives in the US, he's broken more then one law by now.

QUOTE(NOT_VERI_SEXI_BOI^^^ @ Jul 12 2007, 05:13 PM) *
His mom's basement.


yeah, but where does his mom live?

QUOTE(tda @ Jul 12 2007, 05:14 PM) *
I don't think anyone is going to get sued really. I threatened "legal action" in my email to imvu to try and provoke them into action, but to be honest if they called my bluff i'd back down. To hell if i'm spending money on a solicitor just because some little twit who's not got two braincells to rub together decided he would rip my stuff.

All i really want to happen is for imvu to remove my work from his page and possibly ban him from the site, that would suit me just fine. It's the work i care about more than anything else, he can soon be forgotten.


the site would probbly give in to any demands you gave, if you could prove to them he was selling your stuff. samll things like that would want to cover anything bad up... to small to take bad publicity if word got out.

QUOTE(Dante3214 @ Jul 12 2007, 05:15 PM) *
Maybe this guy is in a big oblivion mod hating conspiracy with that guy who hack-tastified tessource.


then why not delete EVERYTHING for TESsource?

QUOTE(Nekulor @ Jul 12 2007, 05:19 PM) *
Break out the grill everyone, ITS BARBECUE TIME!!!


I got the booze, and the watermelon
No. In the immortal words of Stanley Kirk Burrell,
"STOP! Hammertime."
mabye this is that guy who was on here a long time ago... think his name was 'bannannasarepeopleto' or something involving bannannas... he made several threads
insulting admin, specific people, and the forums in general while asking for porn mods all in type similer to 7337 and then when asked why he was being an ass he said that he wanted to be banned 'because it was fun'...
Legally, he has plagarised Bethesda's work because any mod you make with the construction set is owned by Bethesda, and neither you or anyone else can sell it. Its written in the license. What you should do is contact Bethesda and they will take this guy out in a heartbeat.
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 05:30 PM) *
mabye this is that guy who was on here a long time ago... think his name was 'bannannasarepeopleto' or something involving bannannas... he made several threads
insulting admin, specific people, and the forums in general while asking for porn mods all in type similer to 7337 and then when asked why he was being an ass he said that he wanted to be banned 'because it was fun'...


Spot the stereotypical 13 year old tongue.gif
QUOTE(axy @ Jul 12 2007, 05:32 PM) *
Legally, he has plagarised Bethesda's work because any mod you make with the construction set is owned by Bethesda, and neither you or anyone else can sell it. Its written in the license. What you should do is contact Bethesda and they will take this guy out in a heartbeat.

He only stole the models and texture, he never touched to an .esp sold a mod wink.gif
QUOTE(axy @ Jul 12 2007, 10:32 PM) *
Legally, he has plagarised Bethesda's work because any mod you make with the construction set is owned by Bethesda, and neither you or anyone else can sell it. Its written in the license. What you should do is contact Bethesda and they will take this guy out in a heartbeat.


i think you need to read back a bit, administrators from here have already contacted the legal department
LOL this guy looks emo in that photo of himself 24.gif
QUOTE(needahearth @ Jul 12 2007, 05:32 PM) *
Spot the stereotypical 13 year old tongue.gif


I think after he was banned, he started another acount and did it agin... could be wrong though, I only herd about the second time
what exactly is he selling? accessories for avatars on imvd? or was he actually selling the meshes and textures to be used in oblivion?
QUOTE(axy @ Jul 12 2007, 05:44 PM) *
what exactly is he selling? accessories for avatars on imvd? or was he actually selling the meshes and textures to be used in oblivion?


eather way it was illegal... but now that you mention it, I dunno
OT: Wow, 22 users are looking at the same topic. Never seen that before ohmy.gif



@axy: He rigged the models to the IMVU avatars so people could use them or something and he claimed to have made them.
oops, wrong tab.
Ooooh, this gets my blood boiling! *gets torches and pitchforks* We should spam his MSN account on that page...
well if he rigged it and is selling it for avatars, then that is not as illegal as selling the meshes and textures to be used in oblivion. It is still wrong, however.
QUOTE(axy @ Jul 12 2007, 10:51 PM) *
well if he rigged it and is selling it for avatars, then that is not as illegal as selling the meshes and textures to be used in oblivion. It is still wrong, however.



hes selling the meshes n textures from peoples oblivion mods for use on peoples IMVU characters, which are 3d
off topic---22 User(s) are reading this topic... this gotta be a record or something.....

kinda on topic--- can't we all just whine to the imvu guys to ban him?

off topic--- i am so 188.gif i wanna go to this emot-ninja1.gif's house and sterb032.gif his sorry (insert word).... for trying to be a hacker-wannabe.....
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 05:12 PM) *
where does this guy live?

QUOTE(wolfpup @ Jul 12 2007, 05:13 PM) *
Good question, seeing it said Spain earlier, & it know says Canada. blink.gif

It says here that he is in Benghazi, Libya attending Collage!. Some kinda European school. Also says that he is Armenian.

Question? I don't know how things work in Libya but, wouldn't you get expelled from College if you are caught plagiarizing? It's not copying an essay sure, but it's still a big representation of ones own credibility. I know if I ran a collage, and a student of mine was plagiarizing the work of others on the internet, he wouldn't be a student of mine for long.

Too bad he doesn't list his school. What bigger blow that would've been if his school found out...

@axy: He's selling not only several meshes made by Bethesda(thus their property) but he has also ripped off others peoples work, pretended like they was his own and sold them for profit as well, all without the permission of the original authors.

2nd post @axy: It is Illegal to use any content (Textures, sounds, meshes, ect) from one game and convert them for use on any other game, project or platform without the special permission of the software company or authors that owns them and created them. PERIOD

It's the reason that everything that Bethesda made for Morrowind can't be converted to Oblivion and released. They made it for that game and that game only, and have never given permission for the content to be anywhere else. You can recreate it from scratch sure, but a direct conversion is a big no no.
QUOTE(axy @ Jul 12 2007, 05:51 PM) *
well if he rigged it and is selling it for avatars, then that is not as illegal as selling the meshes and textures to be used in oblivion. It is still wrong, however.


actully, it's even MORE illegal, because while he was selling them, their not being sold as something for another company. if that where the case, it's similer to copying every item in WoW and releasing it as a mod for oblivion

QUOTE(crab-man @ Jul 12 2007, 05:56 PM) *
off topic---22 User(s) are reading this topic... this gotta be a record or something.....

kinda on topic--- can't we all just whine to the imvu guys to ban him?

off topic--- i am so 188.gif i wanna go to this emot-ninja1.gif's house and sterb032.gif his sorry (insert word).... for trying to be a hacker-wannabe.....


even if they did ban him, he could just make another account that we don't know of.

QUOTE(Ryu Doppler @ Jul 12 2007, 06:00 PM) *
It says here that he is in Benghazi, Libya attending Collage!. Some kinda European school. Also says that he is Armenian.

Question? I don't know how things work in Libya but, wouldn't you get expelled from College if you are caught plagiarizing? It's not copying an essay sure, but it's still a big representation of ones own credibility. I know if I ran a collage, and a student of mine was plagiarizing the work of others on the internet, he wouldn't be a student of mine for long.

Too bad he doesn't list his school. What bigger blow that would've been if his school found out...

@axy: He's selling not only several meshes made by Bethesda(thus their property) but he has also ripped off others peoples work, pretended like they was his own and sold them for profit as well, all without the permission of the original authors.

2nd post @axy: It is Illegal to use any content (Textures, sounds, meshes, ect) from one game and convert them for use on any other game, project or platform without the special permission of the software company or authors that owns them and created them. PERIOD

It's the reason that everything that Bethesda made for Morrowind can't be converted to Oblivion and released. They made it for that game and that game only, and have never given permission for the content to be anywhere else. You can recreate it from scratch sure, but a direct conversion is a big no no.


he's probbly lying about that to, he's probbly not attending college so mutch as living in his mom's basement trying to make an easy buck off hard-working modders
Now that is really low, well report the selling of mods to Bethesda and let their legal department sort it out as it is a blatant violation of the EULA for the game.....put the little blighter in jail and give him a cell with bubba as public execution is to good for this type of behavior.

Just one mans opinion.
QUOTE(buddah @ Jul 12 2007, 06:07 PM) *
Now that is really low, well report the selling of mods to Bethesda and let their legal department sort it out as it is a blatant violation of the EULA for the game.....put the little blighter in jail and give him a cell with bubba as public execution is to good for this type of behavior.

Just one mans opinion.


O.O
wow, buddah's pissed...

on another note: does ANYONE read the thread before posting...?
I think I saw waalx 's father sword on there too.What a jerk.Anybody notice he has posted some weird "templates" in his pic section.Possibly trying to state that he did make this stuff.Loser......
QUOTE(buddah @ Jul 13 2007, 12:07 AM) *
Now that is really low, well report the selling of mods to Bethesda and let their legal department sort it out as it is a blatant violation of the EULA for the game.....put the little blighter in jail and give him a cell with bubba as public execution is to good for this type of behavior.

Just one mans opinion.


LOLWHUT??! Sailor bubbah!?!?!
what an asre... i really feel sorry for you tda. ur work is awesome and to see some cnut plagiarise it (aswell as other peoples work) really psises me off. it also annoys me that people would actually buy it from that fcuk rather than check out PES and TES...
SUE THIS NUB!!!!
omg what the...
201 !!!!!! whos gonna make another thread?
QUOTE(demoncleaner @ Jul 12 2007, 06:10 PM) *
I think I saw waalx 's father sword on there too.What a jerk.Anybody notice he has posted some weird "templates" in his pic section.Possibly trying to state that he did make this stuff.Loser......


my god... noone READS the THREAD, do they!?

QUOTE(Atarau @ Jul 12 2007, 06:10 PM) *
LOLWHUT??! Sailor bubbah!?!?!


no THAT, is just scary.
while im on id happily start a new thread... before this one gets closed
QUOTE(Dart @ Jul 12 2007, 06:18 PM) *
my god... noone READS the THREAD, do they!?
no THAT, is just scary.

Don't be an ass I read the first four or five pages.
Topic is gonna be locked soon, sadly.
QUOTE(axy @ Jul 13 2007, 09:32 AM) *
Legally, he has plagarised Bethesda's work because any mod you make with the construction set is owned by Bethesda, and neither you or anyone else can sell it. Its written in the license. What you should do is contact Bethesda an acf d they will take this guy out in a heartbeat.

Bethesda owns what you make in the Construction Set, but they don't own any meshes or textures you make, so no he ripped off the modder, not Bethesda.

QUOTE(crab-man @ Jul 13 2007, 09:56 AM) *
off topic---22 User(s) are reading this topic... this gotta be a record or something....

I saw more in the Fallout forums when the Fallout3 trailer was up, it was at least 500 people in the one topic.
Would the models being used in the construction set to make mods perhaps make them Beth's?
QUOTE(demoncleaner @ Jul 12 2007, 06:19 PM) *
Don't be an ass I read the first four or five pages.



ok, so you read half... look, i'm not trying to be an ass or anything, but your the third person who would have had stuff answerd if you had read the rest.
Please, move on to this thread
Submit a Thread